Have you ever wondered why we have so many ugly parking lots? One of the reasons is that we require them by law. We call these mandates “parking minimums.”
People get anxious about getting rid of parking minimums, but do we want our commercial corridors and streets to stay ugly or to have a chance to be beautiful?
Because that’s the real question behind parking minimums. Parking lots are ugly. It’s plain and simple.
We try to decorate them with landscaping, to sprinkle in some trees and crushed granite, maybe even a few pavers, but we are just putting lipstick on a pig. A smelly, disgusting, greasy pig. The less parking you have, the nicer a place is. That’s it. If it hasn’t been proven yet by science, someone just needs to do the study. I apologize that I haven’t gotten around to it.
Let me ask you a question: have you seen a nice parking lot? Maybe they look a little better in an upscale neighborhood like Alamo Heights, surrounded by trees and well-kept buildings, but that’s because of the trees and well-kept buildings. It’s not the parking lot. Venture elsewhere and let me know what you find. When the trees and nice landscaping aren’t there, what do you see?
I can tell you. You see a plain, ugly, hot piece of concrete or asphalt that takes up a tremendous amount of space. Oh, and what a great idea to have these ugly glimmering pieces of glory proliferating everywhere smack dab in one of the hottest states in the country. These enormous parking lots have zero ability to create shade and use materials that absorb and radiate heat. It’s incredible that we complain about the summer weather in San Antonio. We’ve likely made it 20 degrees hotter.
Part of the reason why parking is such a stain on our landscape is because our parking spaces are humongous. Every parking space is almost 200 square feet, the size of a small bedroom, but they are larger than that because you also must have space to go back in and out with your giant car. The real space requirement is closer to 300 square feet, more like a large luxury bedroom. Now imagine 500 of these spaces sizzling in the heat in front of a big box store. Ouch, it hurts.
Do you want to start a cute little neighborhood business like an ice cream stand? Well, parking requirements force you to allocate more space for cars than for the actual shop. Hopefully that chic French-style awning goes well with an ample serving of pavement. Heaven forbid that an ice cream scoop slips off the cone and down to the asphalt in the summer. It will instantly evaporate. Poof. Gone. Now the kids are crying.
They should be crying. We have created deserts of asphalt and concrete with no sense of place or purpose, and we did it to accommodate a giant, expensive, and inefficient machine. We made sure that the kids and everyone else got out of the street and out of the way. But that’s OK. The kids can just play video games and look at social media all day. They’ll be fine.
We need to get rid of parking minimums and guess what? We’ll be OK without them.
If we get rid of parking minimums, property owners aren’t just going to ecstatically rush out of the City Council meeting in a frenzy that night, foaming at the mouth, driving recklessly like animals, just so they can get home and start to implement their repressed dreams of converting their parking spaces into affordable housing. Instead, they have to deal with reality, and the reality is that almost everyone drives in San Antonio. The owner of a retail center would have to be insane to get rid of their parking spaces overnight, because the businesses need parking for their customers and almost all their customers drive.
If businesses, over time, reduce their parking spaces and cars start spilling out to park on neighborhood streets, that could be rough, but it wouldn’t be the end of the world. We can simply just regulate how many cars can park in the neighborhood. We already do this effectively in many residential areas. Resident parking only. Passes for visitors. Specific parking hours. It’s very easy to solve this problem without requiring parking by law.
If we keep parking minimums, we stay the same. Period. Oceans of asphalt. Hot, hot, ugly, desolate, parking lot wastelands with dying strip centers galore. Also, the birds. The ugliest birds. This is perhaps the most important part.
I’m convinced that the hideousness of the parking lot somehow forced the evolution of some poor innocent bird species into the grackle, that anxious, twitchy, nasty little bird that camouflages perfectly with cracked pavement. The poor friendly sparrows. The grackle takes so much from them.
I wouldn’t be surprised if the grackle was on the verge of evolving into something even more atrocious, given how desolate some of our parking lots have become. I might be looking near the shopping carts at H-E-B one day and just see a grackle bopping around fretting, mechanically moving its little legs and beak, scavenging through the gasoline-stained pavement. Then, POP, out of the grackle comes an even uglier bird.
In fact, I think the only reason the grackle hasn’t evolved yet is because somewhere in its DNA and in the wisdom of evolution there is disbelief that humans could have made such an ugly environment. On one wing, there is a pull for the grackle to get even uglier, to adapt, to look more like a parking lot. On the other wing, there is doubt: “Surely, they can’t keep doing this, maybe I just wait this out.”
I hope it waits it out. We can help by getting rid of parking minimums and at least giving our development a chance to be more beautiful. Over time, the ice cream shop will look prettier, and we’ll see more children playing in the streets, and maybe, just maybe, the grackle will thank us, but probably not.
THE VOICE:
David Morin
David is a Partner with MNO Partners, a real estate development firm focused on developing walkable and community-oriented projects throughout the San Antonio-Austin corridor. David is also the founder and (again) owner of Mission Kayak, San Antonio’s first kayak rental company on the San Antonio riverwalk. David also serves on the City of San Antonio Housing Commission’s Breaking Barriers to Affordable Housing Subcommittee and is the Co-Chair for the Urban Land Institute’s Neighborhood Development Local Member Council. In his spare time, David loves to walk through and explore San Antonio, envision its future, and hang out with his wife and two kids (both under two). David and his family are active parishioners of Our Lady of Grace Catholic Church and live in a historic neighborhood near downtown San Antonio.




